The Shift Back to Office: Weighing the Pros and Cons of Increased Salaries for In-Office Work

Olivia Rhye
11 Jan 2022
5 min read

Written by EPHY

As several large companies transition back to in-office work, a significant shift in compensation strategies is emerging. According to Robert Half's 2025 Salary Guide, many managers are considering salary increases for employees who return to the office. Let's explore the pros and cons of this approach.


Pros of Increased Salaries for In-Office Work

Attracting Talent:
Two out of three managers surveyed by Robert Half in June expressed a willingness to increase salaries for new hires who work in an office setting. This can be a powerful incentive to attract top talent who may prefer or be willing to work in an office environment.

Commitment to Office Presence:
Of the employers open to offering a return-to-office premium, 59% indicated they would pay up to 20% more for workers who commit to being in the office between four and five days per week. This financial incentive can encourage employees to maintain a consistent office presence, which some companies believe enhances collaboration and productivity.

Competitive Edge:
Meeting candidates' pay expectations is crucial, as it was identified as the biggest hiring challenge for nearly half of the employers surveyed. Offering higher salaries for in-office roles can give companies a competitive edge in a tight labor market.


Cons of Increased Salaries for In-Office Work

Increased Costs:
Offering up to 20% more in salaries for in-office work can significantly increase operational costs for companies. This may not be sustainable for all businesses, especially smaller ones with limited budgets.

Potential Inequity:
Higher salaries for in-office roles could create disparities between remote and in-office employees, potentially leading to dissatisfaction and a sense of inequity among the workforce.

Work-Life Balance Concerns:
While Robert Half recommends that employers evaluate their pay packages comprehensively, including benefits and opportunities for better work-life balance, focusing solely on salary increases might overlook other important aspects of employee satisfaction and well-being.

Conclusion

As companies navigate the transition back to office-based work, the decision to offer increased salaries for in-office roles presents both opportunities and challenges. While it can be an effective strategy to attract and retain talent, it also requires careful consideration of the potential drawbacks, such as increased costs and equity concerns. Employers are encouraged to take a holistic approach by evaluating and enhancing their overall compensation packages, ensuring they remain competitive while fostering a balanced and inclusive work environment.